CiteNScope — Scholarly Index & Analytics
Discover / Analytics RESEARCH INTELLIGENCE
CiteNScope / Analytics

Explore the evidence.
Understand the reach.

Research across participating journals · All insights follow your collection filters.

Compare journals ↗
OpenAlex coverage 100.0% · 4/4 recordsLast OpenAlex observation 22 Oct 2026, 08:02 UTC
PUBLICATIONS4In the selected collection
CROSSREF CITATIONS84/4 with known counts
OPENALEX CITATIONS94/4 with known counts
OPENALEX MEAN2.25Per article with a known count
Explore articles 4 →
Filter collection Publication years, search & more
Reset
topic: Education Systems and Policy Remove ×
Your research collection

Output and reach

Publication activity alongside incoming citations.

Publication activity

Articles grouped by publication year

Publications

Hover over a year or focus the chart and use arrow keys to inspect values.

2026 is year to date. 0 undated publications excluded.

View data & coverage

Citations received

OpenAlex · year of the citing work

OpenAlex

Hover over a year or focus the chart and use arrow keys to inspect values.

2017–2026 annual-history window. 2026 is year to date. Unknown years have gaps.

View data & coverage

Research landscape

Leading affiliations and themes in this collection.

Full distributions & methodology ↓

Institutions

University of South Africa2Tshwane University of Technology1University of Venda14/4 records with data

Countries

South Africa44/4 records with data

Primary topics

Education Systems and Policy44/4 records with data
Two perspectives on citations

Follow the research impact

Independent sources. Clear time scales.

Lifetime citations by publication year

Crossref and OpenAlex · separate totals for the same publication cohorts

Hover over a year or focus the chart and use arrow keys to inspect values.

Latest lifetime totals, grouped by the cited article’s year. These are not citations received in that year.

View data & coverage

Citations received each year

OpenAlex · incoming citation links grouped by citing-work year

OpenAlex

Hover over a year or focus the chart and use arrow keys to inspect values.

2017–2026 annual-history window. 2026 is year to date. Unknown years have gaps.

View data & coverage
Annual history: 4/4 articles. Latest history observation: 2026-10-22T08:02:07.973854+00:00. Source totals are never added together.
Research side by side

Compare journals

Select journals to compare the same collection filters. Source totals stay separate. These measures describe research activity, not journal quality.

Leave all unchecked to include every matching journal. Selection affects only comparison charts.
Display range
International Journal of Business Ecosystem & StrategyInternational Journal of Research in Business and Social Science

Publications

Articles by publication year

View data & coverage

Crossref citations

Latest lifetime totals · grouped by publication year

View data & coverage

OpenAlex citations

Latest lifetime totals · grouped by publication year

View data & coverage

OpenAlex · Citations received

By year of the citing work · 2017–2026

View data & coverage

2026 is year to date. Crossref and OpenAlex lifetime charts share a citation scale. Unknown observations appear as gaps; known zero stays zero. Annual receipts use available OpenAlex histories and may not sum to lifetime totals. 0 undated publications excluded from publication-year charts.

Full analytics report All distributions, publications, comparisons & data provenance
4 MATCHING PUBLICATIONSExplore results →Export CSV ↓
INDEXED PUBLICATIONS4
CROSSREF CITATIONS8
CROSSREF · CITED PUBLICATIONS50.0%
CROSSREF · MEAN CITATIONS2.0

Crossref citation coverage: 4 / 4 publications (100.0%). Latest observation: 21 Oct 2026, 07:22 UTC. Means and percentages use records with known counts.

OpenAlex / Separate citation source

A broader view of this research

DOI-matched OpenAlex observations for the same selected publications. These counts are separate from Crossref and are never added together.

OPENALEX CITATIONS9
DOI MATCH COVERAGE100.0%4 / 4 publications
MEAN · KNOWN COUNTS ONLY2.254 known · 0 unknown
MEDIAN · KNOWN COUNTS ONLY1.0

Observation range: 21 Oct 2026 07:22 UTC — 22 Oct 2026 08:02 UTC. Missing matches are not zero citations. Previous observations may remain if a refresh fails or a DOI no longer matches.

OpenAlex citation distributionNo citations21–516–20121+0Unknown0

Institutions, countries & topics

OpenAlex affiliations and primary-topic classification. Each publication counts once per institution or country; multi-affiliated publications appear in multiple groups, so percentages can sum above 100%. Countries describe author affiliations, not nationality. Topics use one primary topic per publication.

Institutions

4 / 4 with data · 0 missing or unmatched. Percentages use all 4 selected publications.

Countries

4 / 4 with data · 0 missing or unmatched. Percentages use all 4 selected publications.

Primary topics

4 / 4 with data · 0 missing or unmatched. Percentages use all 4 selected publications.

Citation year / OpenAlex

Citations received over time

Incoming citations to the selected publications, grouped by the year of the citing work. This is separate from lifetime citation totals grouped by the cited article’s publication year.

The publication filters above define which articles receive the citations. The citation-year range below only controls this chart and the incoming-citation comparison. Removing publication-year filters includes older articles’ incoming citations too.

Annual history available for 4 / 4 selected publications. Supported display window: 2017–2026; 2026 is incomplete. Within a successfully fetched ten-year window, omitted years mean zero. Missing histories and years beyond a saved observation’s window remain unknown (—); partial coverage can understate totals.

Annual-history observations (UTC): 2026-10-21T07:22:54.949758+00:00 — 2026-10-22T08:02:07.973854+00:00. Older observations may be retained after failed or incomplete refreshes.

OpenAlex · Citations received by year

42.00 2017 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 0 · Annual history coverage 4/42018 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 0 · Annual history coverage 4/42019 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 0 · Annual history coverage 4/42020 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 0 · Annual history coverage 4/42021 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 0 · Annual history coverage 4/42022 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 0 · Annual history coverage 4/42023 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 0 · Annual history coverage 4/42024 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 1 · Annual history coverage 4/42025 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 4 · Annual history coverage 4/42026 · All selected publications · OpenAlex · Citations received by year: 4 · Annual history coverage 4/4 2017201820192020202120222023202420252026
View openalex · citations received by year data & coverage
Citation yearJournal / scopeOpenAlex · Citations received by yearPublicationsAnnual history known
2017All selected publications044/4
2018All selected publications044/4
2019All selected publications044/4
2020All selected publications044/4
2021All selected publications044/4
2022All selected publications044/4
2023All selected publications044/4
2024All selected publications144/4
2025All selected publications444/4
2026All selected publications444/4

Counts represent citation links, not unique citing papers across a journal: one paper citing two selected articles contributes two links. Older citations outside this window are excluded, so annual sums need not equal lifetime totals. OpenAlex methodology ↗

Crossref citation distribution

Latest Crossref totals for the selected publications; not citations received in the selected years.

Mean2.0
Median1.0
No citations21–516–20121+0Unknown0

Unknown counts are excluded from the mean, median and cited-publication rate.

Journal comparison

Same filters, source and counting rules across journals. Descriptive statistics, not a quality ranking.

Journal / publisherPublicationsCrossref citationsOpenAlex citationsOpenAlex coverageCrossref meanCrossref medianCrossref cited %*Crossref coverage
International Journal of Business Ecosystem & Strategy
Bussecon International Academy
1001/10.000.01/1 · 100.0%
International Journal of Research in Business and Social Science
SSBFNET
3893/32.67266.73/3 · 100.0%

* Percentage among publications with a known citation count.

Explore publications

View all 4 →

Most cited · Crossref

JOURNAL ARTICLE

A deflating quality TVET education in Gauteng Technical, Vocational Education and Training Colleges

Sizwe Mahlangu · Thokozani Mtshali

International Journal of Research in Business and Social Science · 2024

Read abstract

The post-secondary vocational education system in South Africa encounters many challenges, including a lack of professionalism among certain teaching people, an unresponsive curriculum, and inadequate management of day-to-day operations, leading to fragmentation within the system. This is corroborated by a 2014 Training Needs Assessment Study (TNAS) that uncovered a dearth of effective college leadership management abilities and the utilisation of insufficient instructional approaches in certain vocational schools. This study aimed to investigate the possible factors influencing the quality of Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) in certain colleges located in the Gauteng area of South Africa. The study employed a quantitative research methodology, collecting data using a survey. Subsequently, the data was subjected to analysis using SPSS. This study hypothesised that the current state of affairs may be attributed to inadequate and fragmented leadership and management techniques. The researchers expressed uncertainty regarding the implementation of a more integrated and focused leadership approach that would disperse responsibility for student accomplishment in order to enhance outcomes. This study aimed to examine the main obstacles to enhancing students' performance in TVET colleges and explore how a dispersed instructional leadership approach may be conceptualised to tackle these challenges at the institutional level. The study highlights the significance of collaboration and a fair allocation of power and competence to promote a collective leadership vision in the pursuit of enhanced institutional performance in a sector in need of positive results.

DOI 10.20525/ijrbs.v13i3.32246 Crossref citations7 OpenAlex citations
JOURNAL ARTICLE

Why TVET colleges are not attractive places of higher learning for South African high school learners?

Zamandlovu Makola · Itumeleng Dube · Ramodungoane Tabane

International Journal of Research in Business and Social Science · 2023

Read abstract

Annually, South African universities experience an overwhelming number of learners who are interested in enrolling with them because they are viewed as more appealing post-secondary school study options compared to technical and vocational education and training (TVET) colleges. Therefore, it is important to understand high school learners’ views of TVET colleges so that the issue of oversubscription at universities can be addressed and ensure TVET colleges are a favourable option for learners. In South Africa, most studies investigating TVET colleges as study options involve samples primarily of students already enrolled at TVET colleges. Therefore, this study aimed to investigate high school learners’ views on TVET colleges as a study option after high school. A qualitative study was conducted in which data was collected using a qualitative questionnaire from a sample of 42 high school learners from Grades 10, 11, and 12. Three themes were constructed from the data: the pull factors, the push factors, and the expectations of TVET colleges. Several misconceptions and expectations about TVETs were identified. As most studies used TVET students as study samples, the findings in this study have implications for TVET colleges as they provide insights into the perspectives of South African high school learners and how TVET colleges need to market themselves as viable study options.

DOI 10.20525/ijrbs.v12i8.27322 Crossref citations2 OpenAlex citations
JOURNAL ARTICLE

From choice to satisfaction: Understanding qualification selection at TVET college in Limpopo Province

Thivhavhudzi Prince Magoloi · Fhatuwani Ravhuhali

International Journal of Research in Business and Social Science · 2026

Read abstract

In South Africa’s ongoing effort to address youth unemployment and skills shortages, Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) colleges play a critical role in equipping students with practical, market-relevant skills. However, the persistent misalignment between student qualification choices and labour market demands raises questions about the effectiveness of these institutions. This study investigates the factors influencing qualification choices and student satisfaction at TVET College in Limpopo, using an exploratory qualitative design. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with ten purposively selected students enrolled in National Certificate Vocational (NCV) programmes in Civil Engineering and Office Administration. Thematic analysis revealed that students’ choices were shaped by a combination of personal interests, socio-economic constraints, and limited career guidance. Drawing on Social Cognitive Career Theory (SCCT), the study interprets these choices through the lens of self-efficacy, outcome expectations, and personal goals. While many students expressed satisfaction with their qualifications, challenges such as academic misalignment and low employability prospects were evident. The findings highlight the need for strengthened career counselling and curriculum responsiveness to better align student aspirations with labour market realities.

DOI 10.20525/ijrbs.v15i2.49950 Crossref citations0 OpenAlex citations
JOURNAL ARTICLE

Structural and pedagogical challenges in South African rural TVET colleges: A case of the Eastern Cape, KwaZulu-Natal and Limpopo provinces

Tandiwe Mdlungu

International Journal of Business Ecosystem & Strategy · 2026

Read abstract

Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) colleges serve as crucial gateways for South African youth who are unable to access universities due to capacity limitations, financial barriers, or entry requirements. For many rural students, TVET colleges are not just a second choice but the only post-school option available. However, increasing evidence suggests that structural, pedagogical, and governance issues within certain TVET colleges compromise their ability to produce quality, employable graduates. This qualitative study examines systemic challenges that impact teaching quality, lecturer accountability, the language of instruction, admission practices, and student support in rural South African TVET colleges. Drawing on policy documents, academic research, parliamentary reports, and media investigations, the paper examines how these issues perpetuate inequality rather than alleviate it. Special focus is placed on the exclusionary effects of English-only instruction, lecturer oversight, inadequate support systems, dubious recruitment practices, and the admission of under-prepared students into technically demanding programs. The findings identify five interconnected themes that collectively impair graduate employability and student achievement. The study argues that without immediate reforms in lecturer training, accountability systems, and admission standards, TVET colleges risk becoming mere holding institutions instead of pathways to meaningful employment. The paper concludes by recommending stronger oversight, adaptable pedagogy tailored to local contexts, and governance centered on equity, ensuring that TVET colleges fulfil their developmental role in rural South Africa.

DOI 10.36096/ijbes.v8i2.11520 Crossref citations0 OpenAlex citations

Selected results

JOURNAL ARTICLE

Structural and pedagogical challenges in South African rural TVET colleges: A case of the Eastern Cape, KwaZulu-Natal and Limpopo provinces

Tandiwe Mdlungu

International Journal of Business Ecosystem & Strategy · 2026

Read abstract

Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) colleges serve as crucial gateways for South African youth who are unable to access universities due to capacity limitations, financial barriers, or entry requirements. For many rural students, TVET colleges are not just a second choice but the only post-school option available. However, increasing evidence suggests that structural, pedagogical, and governance issues within certain TVET colleges compromise their ability to produce quality, employable graduates. This qualitative study examines systemic challenges that impact teaching quality, lecturer accountability, the language of instruction, admission practices, and student support in rural South African TVET colleges. Drawing on policy documents, academic research, parliamentary reports, and media investigations, the paper examines how these issues perpetuate inequality rather than alleviate it. Special focus is placed on the exclusionary effects of English-only instruction, lecturer oversight, inadequate support systems, dubious recruitment practices, and the admission of under-prepared students into technically demanding programs. The findings identify five interconnected themes that collectively impair graduate employability and student achievement. The study argues that without immediate reforms in lecturer training, accountability systems, and admission standards, TVET colleges risk becoming mere holding institutions instead of pathways to meaningful employment. The paper concludes by recommending stronger oversight, adaptable pedagogy tailored to local contexts, and governance centered on equity, ensuring that TVET colleges fulfil their developmental role in rural South Africa.

DOI 10.36096/ijbes.v8i2.11520 Crossref citations0 OpenAlex citations
JOURNAL ARTICLE

From choice to satisfaction: Understanding qualification selection at TVET college in Limpopo Province

Thivhavhudzi Prince Magoloi · Fhatuwani Ravhuhali

International Journal of Research in Business and Social Science · 2026

Read abstract

In South Africa’s ongoing effort to address youth unemployment and skills shortages, Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) colleges play a critical role in equipping students with practical, market-relevant skills. However, the persistent misalignment between student qualification choices and labour market demands raises questions about the effectiveness of these institutions. This study investigates the factors influencing qualification choices and student satisfaction at TVET College in Limpopo, using an exploratory qualitative design. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with ten purposively selected students enrolled in National Certificate Vocational (NCV) programmes in Civil Engineering and Office Administration. Thematic analysis revealed that students’ choices were shaped by a combination of personal interests, socio-economic constraints, and limited career guidance. Drawing on Social Cognitive Career Theory (SCCT), the study interprets these choices through the lens of self-efficacy, outcome expectations, and personal goals. While many students expressed satisfaction with their qualifications, challenges such as academic misalignment and low employability prospects were evident. The findings highlight the need for strengthened career counselling and curriculum responsiveness to better align student aspirations with labour market realities.

DOI 10.20525/ijrbs.v15i2.49950 Crossref citations0 OpenAlex citations
JOURNAL ARTICLE

A deflating quality TVET education in Gauteng Technical, Vocational Education and Training Colleges

Sizwe Mahlangu · Thokozani Mtshali

International Journal of Research in Business and Social Science · 2024

Read abstract

The post-secondary vocational education system in South Africa encounters many challenges, including a lack of professionalism among certain teaching people, an unresponsive curriculum, and inadequate management of day-to-day operations, leading to fragmentation within the system. This is corroborated by a 2014 Training Needs Assessment Study (TNAS) that uncovered a dearth of effective college leadership management abilities and the utilisation of insufficient instructional approaches in certain vocational schools. This study aimed to investigate the possible factors influencing the quality of Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) in certain colleges located in the Gauteng area of South Africa. The study employed a quantitative research methodology, collecting data using a survey. Subsequently, the data was subjected to analysis using SPSS. This study hypothesised that the current state of affairs may be attributed to inadequate and fragmented leadership and management techniques. The researchers expressed uncertainty regarding the implementation of a more integrated and focused leadership approach that would disperse responsibility for student accomplishment in order to enhance outcomes. This study aimed to examine the main obstacles to enhancing students' performance in TVET colleges and explore how a dispersed instructional leadership approach may be conceptualised to tackle these challenges at the institutional level. The study highlights the significance of collaboration and a fair allocation of power and competence to promote a collective leadership vision in the pursuit of enhanced institutional performance in a sector in need of positive results.

DOI 10.20525/ijrbs.v13i3.32246 Crossref citations7 OpenAlex citations
JOURNAL ARTICLE

Why TVET colleges are not attractive places of higher learning for South African high school learners?

Zamandlovu Makola · Itumeleng Dube · Ramodungoane Tabane

International Journal of Research in Business and Social Science · 2023

Read abstract

Annually, South African universities experience an overwhelming number of learners who are interested in enrolling with them because they are viewed as more appealing post-secondary school study options compared to technical and vocational education and training (TVET) colleges. Therefore, it is important to understand high school learners’ views of TVET colleges so that the issue of oversubscription at universities can be addressed and ensure TVET colleges are a favourable option for learners. In South Africa, most studies investigating TVET colleges as study options involve samples primarily of students already enrolled at TVET colleges. Therefore, this study aimed to investigate high school learners’ views on TVET colleges as a study option after high school. A qualitative study was conducted in which data was collected using a qualitative questionnaire from a sample of 42 high school learners from Grades 10, 11, and 12. Three themes were constructed from the data: the pull factors, the push factors, and the expectations of TVET colleges. Several misconceptions and expectations about TVETs were identified. As most studies used TVET students as study samples, the findings in this study have implications for TVET colleges as they provide insights into the perspectives of South African high school learners and how TVET colleges need to market themselves as viable study options.

DOI 10.20525/ijrbs.v12i8.27322 Crossref citations2 OpenAlex citations

Data coverage & freshness

Source coverage refers to this result set; a publication may occur in several sources. Sync times refer to contributing journals.

Missing abstracts: 0 · Missing authors: 0 · Missing publication dates: 0 · Dates without day precision: 0

SourceMost recent successful journal syncLatest attempt
crossref21 Oct 2026 07:22 UTC · ijrbscomplete · ijrbs · 21 Oct 2026 07:22 UTC
ojs-rest21 Oct 2026 07:22 UTC · ijrbscomplete · ijrbs · 21 Oct 2026 06:46 UTC
oai-pmh20 Oct 2026 19:55 UTC · ijrbscomplete · ijrbs · 20 Oct 2026 19:50 UTC
openalex-enrichment21 Oct 2026 07:23 UTC · ijrbscomplete · ijrbs · 21 Oct 2026 07:22 UTC
Full import history & methodology →