Between expression and equality: Constitutional challenges in adjudicating racially charged political speech in South Africa

Abstract

This article critically examines the constitutional tension between the right to freedom of expression and the rights to equality and dignity in adjudicating racially charged political speech in South Africa. It focuses on the controversial chant "Kill the Boer" and interrogates how courts navigate the competing imperatives of protecting political expression while upholding non-racialism, equality, and human dignity. Through doctrinal and comparative analysis, including cases from Kenya and Rwanda, the article identifies inconsistencies in South African jurisprudence, particularly regarding symbolic speech and its real-world impact on minority communities. It highlights the judiciary's tendency to underplay psychological and symbolic harm, which undermines public trust and the transformative vision of the Constitution. The article further addresses the study's limitations, such as the limited engagement with primary data and potential judicial biases. It proposes reforms that prioritise restorative constitutionalism and a more context-sensitive approach to adjudicating hate speech, considering the feasibility of such measures within South Africa’s resource-constrained legal framework. The study contributes to broader debates on how transitional democracies can address historical injustice without enabling new forms of exclusion or harm.

Keywords: {'name': 'Freedom of expression'}, {'name': 'racial incitement'}, {'name': 'constitutional rights'}, {'name': 'South Africa'}, {'name': 'hate speech'}, {'name': 'political speech'}, {'name': 'equality'}, {'name': 'dignity'}, {'name': 'judiciary'}

Authors & affiliations

Suares Clovis Oukouomi Noutchie
Affiliation not supplied

Deposited references

Supplied references, not a list of publications citing this article.

AfriForum v Economic Freedom Fighters and Others (1105/2022) [2024] ZASCA 82; [2024] 3 All SA 319 (SCA); 2024 (10) BCLR 1275 (SCA); 2024 (6) SA 1 (SCA) (28 May 2024). https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZASCA/2024/82.html

Article 19. (1992). Striking a balance: Hate speech, freedom of expression and non-discrimination. ARTICLE 19. https://www.article19.org/data/files/pdfs/publications/striking-a-balance.pdf

Du Plessis, L. (2008). Interpretation. In S. Woolman & M. Bishop (Eds.), Constitutional law of South Africa (2nd ed., ch. 32). Juta & Co. https://constitutionallawofsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/Chap32.pdf

DOI: 10.17159/1727-3781/2020/v23i0a7520

DOI: 10.4314/pelj.v16i5.8

DOI: 10.2989/CCR.2021.0012

DOI: 10.1080/02587203.1998.11834974

Krüger, R. (2011). Small steps to equal dignity: The work of the South African equality courts. The Equal Rights Review, 7, 27–43. https://www.equalrightstrust.org/ertdocumentbank/ERR7_kruger.pdf

Milo, D., Penfold, G., & Stein, A. (2008). Freedom of expression. In S. Woolman & M. Bishop (Eds.), Constitutional law of South Africa (2nd ed., ch. 42). Juta & Co. https://constitutionallawofsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/Chap42.pdf

DOI: 10.17159/2077-4907/2020/ldd.v24.14

Nyathi, N. (2017). South Africa and Kenya’s legislative measures to prevent hate speech. Conflict Trends, 2017(2). https://www.accord.org.za/conflict-trends/south-africa-kenyas-legislative-measures-prevent-hate-speech/

Nyathi, N. (2018). The poverty of law: A critical analysis of hate speech jurisprudence in South Africa (Master’s thesis, University of Pretoria). University of Pretoria Repository. https://repository.up.ac.za/server/api/core/bitstreams/d9cb41ab-71b8-4d86-a9ba-a2d699141d9d/content

Ramalekana, N. (2021). Towards a transformative approach to affirmative action in South Africa [Doctoral thesis, University of Oxford]. Oxford University Research Archive. https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:f7151de1-2b21-441f-b545-82a8758b6ea2

Scheffler, A. (2015). The inherent danger of hate speech legislation: A case study from Rwanda and Kenya on the failure of a preventative measure. Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung, fesmedia Africa. https://library.fes.de/pdf-files/bueros/africa-media/12462.pdf

Smith, A. (2014). Equality constitutional adjudication in South Africa. African Human Rights Law Journal, 14(2), 609–632.

DOI: 10.4314/pelj.v16i5.7