Rehabilitation versus retribution: How international inspectorates influence prison philosophy and practice<i>?</i>

Abstract

This study examines the ideological impact of international prison inspectorates on national correctional systems, concentrating on how these bodies influence the balance between rehabilitative and retributive penological philosophies. While their primary mandate is to monitor prison conditions and prevent ill-treatment, inspectorates such as the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT), the Optional Protocol to the Convention Against Torture (OPCAT) National Preventive Mechanisms (NPMs), and the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) subtly shape penal ideologies through their engagement and recommendations. The research sets out three objectives: to identify the penological philosophies promoted by selected international inspectorates, to analyse their rhetorical and strategic approaches in influencing prison systems, and to assess the tangible impact of these efforts on national policies and prison practices. A qualitative, comparative case study method is used, incorporating content analysis of inspectorate reports and communications, national legislation, and interviews with key stakeholders. Preliminary findings reveal a consistent promotion of rehabilitative and human rights-based approaches by these bodies. The CPT emphasizes normalization and reintegration, OPCAT NPMs focus increasingly on conditions supporting rehabilitation, and the ICRC advocates humane treatment, which underpins rehabilitative ideals. Impacts include legislative reforms, the introduction of rehabilitation programs, and shifts in official discourse. However, these changes vary across countries and are often limited by political, economic, and cultural barriers. The study concludes that international inspectorates, though often operating subtly, contribute significantly to shifting correctional ideologies toward more balanced, rehabilitative models. It adds to penological scholarship by illuminating the mechanisms through which global oversight fosters internal penal reform.

Keywords: {'name': 'International Prison Inspectorates, Rehabilitative Penology, European Committee For The Prevention Of Torture (CPT), Optional Protocol To The Convention Against Torture (OPCAT), Penal Reform, Prison Conditions Monitoring'}

Authors & affiliations

Ernest Ramokone Lekalakala
Tshwane University of Technology

Deposited references

Supplied references, not a list of publications citing this article.

Association for the Prevention of Torture. (2023). Global prison trends 2023 (inspection & monitoring section).

Babbie, E. (2024). The practice of social research (16th ed.). Cengage.

Barbour, R. (2021). Doing focus groups (2nd ed.). SAGE.

Bazeley, P., & Jackson, K. (2022). Qualitative data analysis with NVivo (4th ed.). SAGE.

DOI: 10.1093/jhuman/huaa030

Carver, R., & Handley, R. (2020). Building capacity for prison reform: The role of oversight bodies. Justice Trends Press.

Council of Europe. (2020). European prison rules: Revisions and implications. Council of Europe.

Council of Europe. (2020). European prison rules (Recommendation Rec (2006)2-rev, revised 2020). Council of Europe Publishing.

Council of Europe Committee of Ministers. (2020). Recommendation Rec (2006)2-rev on the European Prison Rules (as revised in 2020).

Council of Europe European Committee for the Prevention of Torture. (2024). 34th general report on the CPT's activities.

Creswell, J. W., & Poth, C. N. (2023). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches (5th ed.). SAGE.

European Parliamentary Research Service. (2025). European prison rules: A comprehensive overview.

European Parliamentary Research Service. (2025). Prisons and detention in the EU.

European Penitentiary Training Academies Network. (2023). Nelson Mandela Rules International Training Programme, trainer's manual: Guidance for prison staff training on minimum standards.

Global News. (2025). SPT denied access to Australian detention facilities.

Penal Reform International & Thailand Institute of Justice. (2025). Global prison trends 2025.

Goldson, B., & Kilkelly, U. (2025). National preventive mechanisms under OPCAT: Expanding roles and responsibilities. Human Rights Quarterly, 47(2), 123–145.

Goldson, B., & Kilkelly, U. (2025). Preventive detention monitoring is effective: A case study on preventing ill-treatment of children in detention. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology. Advance online publication.

Goodale, M., & Godin, M. (2023). The cruel optimism of international prison regulation: Prison ontologies and carceral harms. Law & Social Inquiry, 48(4), 1203–1230.

Guest, G., Namey, E., & Mitchell, M. (2025). Collecting qualitative data: A field manual for applied research. SAGE.

Hafner, G., Stark, J., & Wiegand, M. (2021). The role of OPCAT National Preventive Mechanisms in prison reform. Human Rights Quarterly, 43(2), 321–346.

International Committee of the Red Cross. (2024). Supporting reintegration and prison maintenance (ICRC reflections, ICPA conference).

International Committee of the Red Cross. (2024, March 26). Red Cross is stepping up prison visits in Somalia. ICRC Newsroom.

International Committee of the Red Cross. (2024, November 7). Prisons in Africa need to be better managed to ensure decent conditions of detention.

International Committee of the Red Cross. (2025, January 15). Bangladesh: Inspector General of Prisons optimistic about transforming prison system with ICRC support.

International Committee of the Red Cross. (2025, June 19). 25 African nations unite to reimagine prison infrastructure with rehabilitation at core (ICPA-ICRC workshop).

International Committee of the Red Cross. (2025a). Complying with IHL in large-scale conflicts: Detention operations in international armed conflicts. Law & Policy Blog.

International Committee of the Red Cross. (2025b). Yemen: 153 detainees released with the support of the ICRC. News Release.

Israel, M., & Hay, I. (2023). Research ethics for social scientists (3rd ed.). SAGE.

DOI: 10.1093/jhuman/huab001

Lee, A. (2025). Principles of effective penal oversight [Forthcoming].

Lee, M. (2025). Principles of effective prison oversight: Independence, transparency, and engagement. Journal of Penological Studies, 58(1), 89–112.

DOI: 10.1093/ia/iiae237

Luna, E. (2025). Retribution and rehabilitation: Philosophical foundations of penology. Oxford University Press.

Luna, F. (2025). The historical origins and evolution of rehabilitative punishment. Journal of Law & Courts, 13(1), 1–28.

Meyer, S., & Denove, S. (2024). Humanitarian oversight: The ICRC's influence in conflict-zone detention reform. Refugee Law Journal, 35(1), 45–68.

Miller, P. (2025). A hybrid model of justice: Combining retribution and rehabilitation. Cambridge University Press.

Møller, L., & Skinnari, J. (2022). Penal policy harmonization and inspectorate influence: The case of Norway and South Africa. Comparative Criminal Law Review, 10(3), 201–228.

Normalization Principle. (2025). Wikipedia.

Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights & Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture. (2025). Statement at the presentation of the SPT's 18th annual report.

Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. (2025). The role of National Preventive Mechanisms. United Nations.

Penal Reform International. (2023). Guidance document on the European Prison Rules (summarising Rule 5 "normalisation").

Penal Reform International. (2024). Global prison trends 2024.

Penal Reform International. (2025). Global prison trends 2025.

Sentencing Project. (2024). A matter of life: The scope and impact of life and long-term imprisonment in the United States.

DOI: 10.1136/bmjgh-2024-017321

South African Department of Correctional Services. (2025, July 18). Correctional services on work commencing at Nelson Mandela Rules Training Academy at Drakenstein Correctional.

Springer, D. (2024). The role of political ideology in agreement with prisoner safety and wellness. SpringerLink.

Springer, S. (2025). Examining the relation between education, recidivism & crime reduction in prisons. SpringerLink.

Tandfonline. (2024). What contributes to fewer cases of recidivism? Treatment, education, and programmes.

Transforming Correctional Culture and Climate. (2024, April 11). National Institute of Justice: U.S. correctional facilities are piloting humane, restorative justice–informed environments.

UK National Preventive Mechanism. (2024). Monitoring places of detention: 15th annual report 2023/24.

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2022). Women in prisons: Nelson Mandela Rules. Regional training for female prison officers in Somaliland is improving humane treatment knowledge.

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2023/2024). United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules).

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2024). Global prison population and trends (brief, incl. rehabilitation activities).

van Stokkom, B. (2022). The Council of Europe's CPT and the evolution of normalization discourse. European Journal of Penology, 39(4), 433–449.

DOI: 10.1093/hrlr/ngaf013

DOI: 10.1093/isagsq/ksaf013