Indexation Of Consumer And Mortgage Credit In Iceland In 2014

Abstract

Six years after the financial crisis that led to the collapse of the banking system in 2008, the over-indebtedness of households is one of the most important problems in Iceland. This study aims to cast light on a specific feature of the Icelandic credit system in connection with the problem of over-indebtedness. The main research question is whether the end of indexation of credit is close or not. The author argues, in the first place, that indexation of credit ex-post to the consumer price index (CPI) in negative amortization schemes is responsible for over-indebtedness. In the second place, the author describes the challenges ahead in the field of consumer and mortgage credit in Iceland in the light of European law (European Union EU and European Economic Area EEA). The incorporation of Directive 2008/48 on credit agreement for consumers to the Icelandic domestic order through the EEA Agreement allowed a preliminary legal review of the practice in light of EU/EEA consumer credit law, both at national and European level without a final conclusion. It has nevertheless led to the judicial review on the legality of some indexation alleged malpractices before national courts and to the EFTA Court for interpretation (mostly on Directives 93/13/EEC on unfair terms 87/102/EEC on consumer credit). A ruling from the Supreme Court is expected on several cases. A critical battle between the legality, the fairness and the legitimacy of indexation of credit is taking place in Iceland under the influence of European law.

Keywords: {'name': 'Indexation of credit'}, {'name': 'European Economic Area'}, {'name': 'Consumer law'}, {'name': 'Iceland'}

Authors & affiliations

Maria Elvira Mendez Pinedo
Affiliation not supplied

Deposited references

Supplied references, not a list of publications citing this article.

Arnarson, E. (2009a). Questionable indexation? Inflation and home-buyers debt, SFR 2.

Arnason, E. (2009b). Unusual times call for unusual measures, Reykjavík´s Municipal Employees Association Newsletter 1.

Bloomberg (2013). Iceland Banks Face US$ 3.3 Billion Loss in Debt Relief Lawsuits.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-09-05/iceland-s-banks-face-3-3-billion-loss-in-debt-relief-lawsuits.html

DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.2504531

http://hdl.handle.net/1814/32451

DV (2014). Lánið hækkað um 11 milljónir: Sýnir hvernig almenningur er blekktur (Loan increases about 11 millions: shows how the public is cheated)

http://www.dv.is/neytendur/2014/9/1/lanid-haekkad-um-11-milljonir-synir-hvernig-almenningur-er-blekktur/

Elíasson, L. (2014). Indexation 101. Central Bank of Iceland. Economic Affairs 6. http://www.sedlabanki.is/lisalib/getfile.aspx?itemid=527b678a-8380-11e3-93f5-005056bc0bdb

ESA. European Surveillance Authority (2013). Iceland must lift ban on exchange rate indexation of loans in ISK.

http://www.eftasurv.int/press--publications/press-releases/internal-market/nr/1977

Eyjan ( 2013). Bankarnir þurfa hugsanlega að aðskrifa 400 milljarda (Banks must probably write-off 400 billions ISK).

eyjan.pressan.is/frettir/2013/09/05/bankarnir-thurfa-hugsanlega-ad-afskrifa-400-milljarda/.

HH. Hagsmunasamtök heimilanna (2014) (The Homes Association). About financial indexation.

http://www.heimilin.is/varnarthing/english.html

Iceland. Ministry of Welfare (2013). Greinargerð um fjárhagsstöðu heimilanna (Analysis of financial situation of households).

http://www.velferdarraduneyti.is/rit-og-skyrslur-vel/nr/33807

Iceland. Prime Ministers´Office (2013a). Neytendavernd á fjármálamarkaði (Report on Consumer Protection in the Financial Markets).

http://www.forsaetisraduneyti.is/media/Skyrslur/neytendavernd-a-fjarmalamarkadi.pdf

Iceland. Prime Minister's Office (2013b). Action Plan for Household Debt Relief. http://eng.forsaetisraduneyti.is/debt-relief/

Iceland. Prime Minister's Office (2013c). Reduction of the Principal of Housing Mortgages. http://www.forsaetisraduneyti.is/media/Skyrslur/reduction-housing-mortgages.pdf

Iceland. Reply of the Minister of Finance to Member of Parliament Margrét Tryggvadóttir (2013) in Icelandic at althingi.is/altext/141/s/1156.html

Iturmendi Morales, J. and Pattaro, E. (1980). Filosofía del Derecho: Derecho y ciencia jurídica. Madrid: Reus.

IMF (2014). Iceland. Country Reports.

https://www.imf.org/external/country/isl/

Jónsson, S. Jóhannesson,S. Árman,V. Benaben, B. and Perrucci, S. (2012). Nauðsyn eða val? Verðtrygging, vextir og verðbólga (Necessity or choice? Indexation, interest and inflation). Reykjavík: SFF (Association of Financial Companies in Iceland).

sff.is/sites/default/files/naudsyn_eda_val-verdtrygging_vextir_og_verdbolga.pdf

Madariaga, A. (2009). Modelos de desarrollo, políticas públicas y desigualdad en el capitalismo chileno. El caso de la política de indexación económica. Centro de Estudios Nacionales de Desarrollo Alternativo. Revista Nemesis (7), 99-112 https://sites.google.com/a/cendachile.cl/cenda/Home/publicaciones/autores/aldo-madariaga/informes-de-investigacion/indexacion-y-distribucion-del-ingreso.

Mallett, J. (2013). An examination of the effect on the Icelandic Banking System of Verðtryggð Lán (Indexed-Linked Loans). University of Reykjavik. Icelandic Institute for Intelligent Machines. Report IIIMTR-2013-01-001. Cornell University Library. arxiv.org/pdf/1302.4112v1.pdf.

Méndez-Pinedo, M. E.(2009). EC and EEA law. A comparative study on the effectiveness of European law. Europa Law Publishing: Groningen.

Méndez-Pinedo, M. E. and Hannesson, O.I. (2013). The authority of European law: exploring primacy of EU law and effect of EEA law from European and Icelandic Perspectives. Law Institute (Lagastofnun). University of Iceland: Reykjavik.

Morgunblaðið (1993). Bankarnir hafa ekki getað keypt viðskiptaskuldabréf eftir 1. Október. 6 October 1993.

http://www.mbl.is/greinasafn/grein/113212/

Morgunblaðið (1994). Lögum um neytendalán breytt vegna annmark. 26 July 1994.

http://www.mbl.is/greinasafn/grein/147787/

Ólafsson, T. and Vignisdóttir, K. (2012). Households’position in the financial crisis in Iceland. Central Bank of Iceland, Economics Department, Working paper 59. cb.is/library/Skr%C3%A1arsafn---EN/Working-Papers/Working%20Paper%2059.pdf

DOI: 10.1093/ojls/gqi042

Robert, Z. (2014). Sixty-Nine Thousand Apply for Debt Cancelation. Iceland Review. http://icelandreview.com/news/2014/09/03/sixty-nine-thousand-apply-debt-cancelation

DOI: 10.54648/ERPL2013040